Home / Sport / Giants Top 5 Coaching Candidates: Who should replace Ben McAdoo?

Giants Top 5 Coaching Candidates: Who should replace Ben McAdoo?


Here is the Daily News’ top five Giants coaching candidates.


Josh McDaniels, Patriots offensive coordinator


It helps to have Tom Brady on the resume, but it also helps Brady to have a creative state-of-the-art offensive mind devising passing schemes. McDaniels failed in less than two seasons as Broncos head coach but Belichick failed in five seasons as the Browns coach. The Giants QB of the future will either be Davis Webb or Sam Darnold/Josh Rosen and McDaniels is the right guy to train him. His key hire will be defensive coordinator and keeping Steve Spagnulo would be a good decision.

Josh McDaniels has been praised for having a creative offensive mind.

(Jim Mahoney/AP)


Bill Cowher, CBS NFL Today


This is more of a wish-list entry. He’s got the perfect personality for New York. The issue is he loves living in New York and his pressure-free lifestyle. Even so, I would call him. He left the Steelers after the 2006 season and hasn’t come close to getting back into coaching. But this is the New York Football Giants. It has to be tempting.


David Shaw, Stanford


He has resisted overtures from the NFL to leave Stanford. He has a great resume, including nine years as an NFL assistant from 1997-2005 with the Eagles, Raiders and Ravens. He coached Andrew Luck his senior year at Stanford and there are rumors the Colts want him. He’s an offensive coach. The Giants have never had an African-American head coach. Last weekend with Geno Smith the Giants became the last team to start a black quarterback.

Giants co-owner Mara should have known better, doesn’t get a pass

David Shaw has resisted temptations to leave for the NFL, but the Giants should still try to pry him away.

David Shaw has resisted temptations to leave for the NFL, but the Giants should still try to pry him away.

(Harry How/Getty Images)


Nick Saban, Alabama


The Giants thought they had him in 1997 before they hired Jim Fassel. They wanted him again in 2004 before they hired Tom Coughlin but he wasn’t home for their phone call at an appointed time and they backed off. He was just 15-17 in two years with the Dolphins between LSU and Alabama jobs. Why would he leave? He has a huge ego, he failed with the Dolphins and it’s New York.


Steve Spagnuolo, Giants defensive coordinator


He has four games to make his case as interim coach for the full-time job. Spags has already been promised he will be considered. He worked with GM candidate Dave Gettleman with the Giants in 2007-08. He has done well in two stints as Giants defensive coordinator but had a rough three years as Rams head coach (10-38) from 2009-11.

Tags:
nfl
new york giants
ben mcadoo
john mara
lists

Send a Letter to the Editor

Join the Conversation:
facebook
Tweet

Gary Myers

About admin

Check Also

NBA games Wednesday, scores, highlights: Paul, Harden lift Rockets to 11th straight W

It was a busy nine-game slate on this NBA Wednesday. We have all the scores, ...

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *